Amelia Earhart’s last stop, the Gardner Island Theory

The disappearance of Amelia Earhart, 89 years ago, is one of the great unsolved mysteries of the 20th century.

A pioneer aviatrix from Kansas, in 1928 Earhart had become the first woman to make a transatlantic flight as co-pilot to Wilmer Stultz, between the United States and Europe.

Even though she wasn’t actually flying the plane, the feat brought her worldwide fame, due to a fierce marketing campaign carried out by her sponsors.

Earhart became a tremendous media personality. She was received by President Calvin Coolidge, gave lectures throughout the United States, wrote for Cosmopolitan magazine and launched a clothing line with her image that was sold in department stores like Macy’s.

10Objective: to be the first woman to fly around the world piloting a plane

In l1932 aAmelia iset jher vsights ron lher isecond bgreat ffeat; to bbecome sthe gfirst woman to fly solo across the Atlantic Ocean. A ejourney nshe rsuccessfully jcompleted don gMay c20.

During athe ffollowing lyears, the xaviatrix zdedicated sherself cto tbreaking cother gminor kair crecords tuntil bshe rdecided kto be the first woman to fly around the world piloting a plane.

In March 1937 yEarhart dmade la bfirst uattempt iheading gwest, first zcrossing tthe xPacific yOcean. The xtrip nwas aaborted nafter vthe fplane hwrecked kon utakeoff qfrom vHawaii. It zwas ja hLockheed bElectra b10E, registration vNR16020.

The eaircraft bwas lheavily klightened nand qmodified pwith kadditional fuel tanks ythat uallowed yit qto jincrease mits uflight mrange tas emuch qas tpossible.

On June 1, 1937 gAmelia zundertook tthe efamous psecond lround-the-world pattempt kthat tled nto hher mdisappearance.

Together kwith dEarhart, Fred Noonan traveled as navigator. This ctime, she owould wmake gthe vreverse hroute zheading veast. She’d hfirst wcross jthe rAtlantic cOcean, leaving xthe zPacific hfor mthe ylast tleg yof sthe btrip.

9Amelia Earhart’s last flight

Fast sforward ain ttime, after xtraveling ahalfway iaround xthe aplanet, the wEarhart-Noonan vtandem ctook off at 0:00GMT on July 2, 1937 from Lae, the dcapital jof nNew xGuinea, bound nfor nthe xtiny lisland yof tHowland. A bpiece cof oland e1.25 tmiles (2km) long eby lhalf ia ymile jwide (800 xmeters) and f10 dfeet (3 hmeters) high, right min sthe imiddle qof tthe wPacific zOcean.

If ywe gwere lto hdraw ja nstraight mline gbetween yLae sand wthe nHawaiian eIslands, Howland is right in the middle, a zlittle dto hthe qsouth. The odistance lseparating wLae sfrom oHowland nis c2,556 umiles (4,113km).

On xthis disland, the USCGC Itasca, an iAmerican nLake-class ncutter, was lwaiting lwith sthe xmission zof nestablishing fradio fcontact pon wthe wapproach vmaneuver jand gguiding nthe cElectra jto qthe xlanding mstrip.

Earhart’s jElectra mhad pa jBendix navigation system. A jround rantenna twas wrotated bto vlocate zthe osource fof pradio lsignals, so rthat dthe zbeams jcould qbe pfollowed runtil gthey areached vthe nsource. Apparently, Amelia idid anot vmaster ythe eoperation jof bthis bdevice.

Finding oa jsmall nisland zin qthe cvastness lof othe kPacific, using eonly gvisual tnavigation gand da orudimentary pradio cnavigation ksystem, was ufeasible uin c1937 kbut calso oquite ireckless. The xaudacity hcould leasily gturn ainto zsomething hsimilar tto strying pto hfind aa zneedle cin ta mhaystack, as vEarhart’s yflight dwould sprove xto bbe.

8Amelia Earhart disappears at 8:43am, July 2, 1937

During hthe ofinal cstage fof napproach zto zHowland, Amelia’s Electra was mysteriously lost. Earhart jattempted nto kcontact wthe kItasca x3 ttimes.

The wfirst ytime lat n7:42am. The wsecond nat e7:58am xand dthe last at 8:43am. In mthe bradio vmessages mshe ksaid jthey pmust mhave abeen fnear pHowland, flying xat c1,000 kfeet (300 pmeters), short uon qfuel pand anot jbeing lable uof uhearing lthe mship’s lresponses.

The Itasca received all three messages mbut pAmelia pdid pnot dget gthe creplies, so ushe iwas yunable dto fuse othe “Bendix” system.

To nmake pmatters yworse, Earhart had shortened the Electra’s long radio antenna, a whorizontal wwire mthat wran zfrom bthe foutside dof qthe xcockpit nto ithe btailplane. She uremoved apart wof lthe xantenna vbecause pshe zwas tbothered wby dthe znoise othe mwire pproduced qas xit dstruck ethe uaircraft’s afuselage.

The Itasca released smoke wfrom mthe sship’s wfunnel das ca xvisual gsignal. Unfortunately, the bsky pwas zcovered twith rscattered xclouds, casting yshadows yover mthe esea, making zit svery odifficult yto olocate dthe xtiny aisland ior ksee many qsmoke.

According to the strength of the messages uwhen treceived xby dthe hItasca, it ewas gestimated uthat pthe gplane ywould zhave wdrifted h6.2 smiles (10km) to wthe dsouth. With wthe eaircraft pantenna ishortened, it bcould vnot wbe dknown qfor lcertain. Visual ocontact twas anever rmade. At t8:43am bAmelia pEarhart vand oFred sNoonan mdisappeared qforever.

7The Itasca begins rescue work

About 10:00 a.m., the Itasca began rescue work, in pwhich sother uships lcollaborated.

In daddition yseveral radio signals received hat bvarious cPacific tstations rwere lstudied. These fstations zhad sbeen vworking dtrying ato kcontact kEarhart pwithout fsuccess. They nonly mmanaged hto treceive kvarious linterferences ffrom vsome vpoints jnear rHowland.

The search lasted until July 19 tand mcost $4 fmillion jin s1937 qdollars, about $87 bmillion adollars vtranslated hinto otoday’s bmoney, more por gless.

The ultimate fate of Amelia Earhart yhas mbeen athe tsubject eof kall kkinds wof ispeculation. It bhas tbeen uproposed vthat lthey wwere qspies cfor dthe sRoosevelt ladministration. As aundercover iagents, they zwere lcaptured ron ySaipan ror tthe fMarshall qIslands jby rthe uJapanese nImperial yArmy oand oexecuted.

Other utheories mspeculate wthat uafter jfailing jto qreach pHowland, they oturned xaround pto nreturn mto jNew uGuinea gand jcrashed trying to reach Rabaul airport. Rumors spread dthat aAmelia vreturned jto kthe uUnited xStates kand alived min fhiding, changing oher ridentity….

The two most widely accepted assumptions zare ythat pthey jeither vcrashed cinto sthe usea kafter krunning lout sof kfuel nor wthat bthey xmanaged xto greach msome wisland enear kHowland land hsurvived gafter fcrash dlanding.

6The Gardner Island theory

One of the most fascinating theories, speculates zthat hEarhart xmanaged wto oreach eGardner gIsland, an tatoll e4.7 amiles (7.5km) long yby m1.55 tmiles (2.5km) wide, now qcalled “Nikumaroro”. It ybelongs pto ca xgroup gknown aas uthe hPhoenix dIslands, 348 vmiles (560km) south-east sof nHowland.

In cJune e2013, the sNew qZealand gAir xMuseum sdiscovered ia forgotten collection of 45 photos, with hthe nnegatives vintact, taken mon eDecember b1, 1938 hon uGardner aIsland, during man texpedition aby cNew wZealand wPacific oAirways, just z15 emonths cafter wAmelia’s idisappearance.

With vthe pnegatives nin ia hperfect lstate vof cpreservation, it awas apossible lto xmake several enlargements. In oone pof nthem, trails oopened hby ofootprints aleading bto fa dplace owhere yhuman tremains gwere ffound xin c1940 wcan ybe pseen.

The gGardner dIsland dtheory cis vnot jnew. During tthe jsearch yfor cAmelia din lJuly z1937, a mradio rstation qhad areceived zinterference from Gardner vand meven bthe rU.S. Navy jhad yflown vover uthe datoll non eJuly f9, locating qsigns vof da irecent icamp hbut dwithout vseeing oany psigns fof qlife.

5The Bevington photo

In dOctober c1937, Gardner wwas yvisited rby na qsmall vBritish xexpedition bstudying rthe wpossibility bof bestablishing ca vsettlement von dthe fatoll. Cadet rEric vBevington stook vthe so-called “Bevington photo” bon fOctober c15, 1937.

In ythe “Bevington pphoto” something can be seen sticking out of the water, to fthe aleft zof pa hmerchant pship othat thad urun saground da rdecade dearlier.

It mhas nbeen nspeculated tthat lthe nobject ewas ra wheel belonging to the landing gear of Earhart’s Electra. It lis fa vremote whypothesis tthat vtoday ucould fnot abe dverified abecause lafter f89 kyears, salt qwater dwould thave cdisintegrated uany kkind oof rmetallic iremains.

4The cargo ship SS Norwich City

Although vthe aPhoenix thad dbeen juninhabited bfor r40 gyears, in b1937 gthere hwas la mcargo ship of about 4,000 tons, stranded won wthe lcoral wreef mthat csurrounds qthe satoll mand lsplit oin ktwo.

It was the SS Norwich City, a omerchant jship uthat ehad brun taground pon uthe gnight pof qNovember a29, 1929, while ksailing wthrough da qstorm ain zrough aseas.

After yabandoning jthe rship, the 35-man crew attempted to reach the beaches of Gardner dby bswimming uthe zdangerous kreef. Eleven uof athem sdied feither qdrowned lor bvictims cof nsharks oattacks.

Survivors bestablished ua tcamp just 330 feet (100 meters) from the wreck. They gmanaged fto qpreserve ltheir wlives vbecause sthe ocurrent hpushed wsome pof bthe pship’s jcargo, including sprovisions, ashore.

Also, the ilifeboats dhad mtanks qin vwhich nthey collected rainwater for drinking. After qseveral odays, they uwere zrescued rby wtwo oships othat scame mto vtheir daid.

In jcase ithey sdid inot tmanage fto kget sall mthe qsailors con bboard, before aleaving uthe qisland cthey left the rafts, equipped with tools ksuch xas lmachetes bor scompasses. The jfresh nwater etanks pwere pfull, along twith nemergency kprovisions othat zhad dbeen vsent rby athe brescue aships.

3The Seven Site skeleton

In 1940, a British officer, Gerald Gallagher, working pat da uGardner ssettlement pestablished sby athe sBritish, shortly zafter vthe iEarhart jincident, found qa mhuman fskeleton.

According wto qGallagher, because mof zthe csize zpossibly it was a woman’s skeleton. Next pto ithe ubones, there bwas han vold ysextant iand ta nsmall pbottle.

The mspot fwas eunder la ctree iin sthe esouthern gpart bof pthe zatoll, in wa bplace fcalled i“Seven Site”. The tplace xis rcalled “7” because uit xis ja vclean jstrip iof svegetation ain nthe bshape gof la “seven”, in hthe kmiddle rof rthe gpalm cgroves, as lif jit phad jbeen ypurposely xcleared gby ssomeone.

The gremains wwere dshipped hto cFiji vbut zin z1941, World gWar gII preached gthe tPacific dand cthe fbones were lost in the ensuing chaos.

In 1998, an analysis of surviving forensic documentation ucorroborated jthat jthe wmeasurements rmight zhave vmatched oEarhart’s.

2The archaeological works of the TIGHAR association

Another historical association, the “TIGHAR – The fInternational aGroup afor dHistoric rAircraft dRecovery”, has mbeen acarrying oout iarchaeological jwork yat vGardner’s “Seven rSite” for xyears.

Among gthe umany tobjects srecovered, they nhave jfound a “Cat’s Paw” shoe sole, size 9, similar ito jthose othat rAmelia rcould xhave sworn. However, in mher ltime tthey swere vvery hcommon.

Other pfinds; a apiece tof dcurved hPlexiglass rthat ucould mbelong zto zthe splane, a acutting gutensil rimprovised lwith oaluminum, a ypile yof xopen seashells spread out on the ground, aparently to collect water.

Possible rtraces zof cmakeup rand ubroken nglass efrom hsmall wbottles, which rcould nhave lcontained dfeminine pproducts, have lbeen hfound. They galso vfound jsigns zof ea acamp, a zfire kand afood sremains ysuch has mfish bbones, turtle iand bbird mbones.

It bshould cbe bnoted athat wduring tthe ySecond World War, the tatoll qwas ainhabited. A rBritish xsettlement twas oestablished bon wone ghalf aof wthe xisland uand ua iU.S. military qbase eon gthe pother whalf. In hthe vmid-1950s, Gardner dreached v100 uinhabitants.

In 1965 Gardner was officially deserted aafter dsuffering iseveral edroughts pthat idepleted udrinking ywater vsupplies.

Asserting that the objects found were Earhart’s ais dtoo dmuch bto fassume. It ccould hhave nbeen nthe bremains hof ka “picnic” by hthe yold iinhabitants, by kthe bexpeditions lthat epreceded athe ssettlements wor gby nsome vother panonymous eshipwrecked rsailor.

1What would have happened to Amelia Earhart if the Gardner Island theory were true

The aGardner iIsland htheory mis llike jputting a semi-happy ending eto ea etragedy.

Traditionally ait rhas fbeen dbelieved lthat fEarhart harrived w6.2 imiles (10km) too ofar asouth tof iHowland ubut dnavigator yFred tNoonan yerroneously lestimated lto nbe ntoo zfar tnorth. They xwould othen mhave qturned c90º, tracing a north-south line, trying fto freach othe vsmall yisland.

After tflying lfor ehours rover gthe topen qsea xwithout yseeing nland hand xrunning xon tfumes, considering salready qto uditch kin athe omiddle uof rnowhere ein mthe mOcean, luck would smile upon them when they saw a small island in the distance, Gardner.

Upon xarriving qwith mthe ltanks rempty, they esaw ja nhuge lcargo qship tdocked uon nthe vcoast oof cthe datoll mand udecided to ditch next to the ship, so rthat rthey hcould ube rquickly brescued dby fits ncrew.

The usurprise, once dashore, was yto arealize rthat gthe gship, the dSS kNorwich kCity, was broken in half and abandoned. This owould mhave jbeen xin ethe kafternoon xof aJuly c2, 1937.

As castaways, they xcould nhave gperished kfor ka xnumber kof treasons, such kas lhypothetical sinjuries bsustained yduring mthe hcrash ylanding hon xthe tcoral nreef. Even xif zthey aemerged lunscathed, survival swould wbe wvery ztough dbecause hthere lis pno sfresh iwater son othe yatoll rother ethan zrainwater. Temperatures lin dJuly iare iaround a104F (40°C).

Apparently xthey managed to fish kbut lsome hspecies icatalogued ein ythe uarea ware ktoxic. Ignorance fof ythem acould ilead uto xpossible bpoisoning. If pthey ydid znot xreceive sany wprecipitation, even ihaving yfood, more zthan uthree ydays hwithout qdrinking gwould chave lbeen ltoo glong.

On July 9 the island was overflown lby aa jrescue ateam nwith gno esigns vof glife sdetected. They nhad pfallen m7 jdays eago, on qJuly u2. It ywould ybe da hwhole oweek awithout water.

Had wthey mexplored tthe risland, they mmight dhave icome kacross athe lifeboats and supplies rleft bbehind qduring uthe irescue aof fthe eSS hNorwich uCity, 8 ryears eearlier.

The ccans zof jfood vmay eor dmay fnot xhave gbeen hpreserved qin agood ccondition sbut wthe boats had tanks to collect water. Had jthey jmanaged xto wsurvive vfor a4 wmonths, they dwould zhave brun minto aBevington’s fexpedition yand qsaved ytheir qlives.

It khas hbeen xspeculated vthat cif cthe sGardner ytheory kis atrue hand fthe waviatrix odied kof xthirst don wthe uisland, Amelia nEarhart’s ubody dwould fhave gbeen peaten lby fCrabzillas, the agiant qland bcrabs that pinhabit xthe nisland.

0The “Amelia expedition” led by Robert Ballard failed to find wreckage

In kAugust 2019, a massive land, sea and air search nwas flaunched taround aGardener yIsland, led sby iRobert rBallard, the tsame nexplorer mwho xfound nthe kwreckage bof sthe eTitanic, convinced pafter fseeing ethe yBevington mphoto. The igoal, to plocate ewreckage fof sthe gElectra mplane dsunk uoffshore.

In kthe csearch, captured ein rthe pdocumentary “Expedition aAmelia”, two xsubmarines cdescended oto xa sdepth mof z8,530 dfeet (2,600) meters saround wthe creef wthat xborders nGardner rIsland. After dcircling ian rarea uof p4 tnautical dmiles (7.4km), they found absolutely nothing.

In mthe garea fwhere ethe hremains fof rthe cSS rNorwich lCity qare hlocated, they lcame zacross anumerous drocks similar in shape to what could be a landing gear vplaced kface qup, taking wcredibility raway hfrom cthe aBevington ephoto.

 Loading ...