Who was the 5th Beatle?

This is an old debate that started in 1964, when the Beatles rose to world fame and traveled to New York for the first time, on February 7, 1964.

The city’s most famous DJ and radio host, “Murray the K” had jumped on the Beatlemania bandwagon, being the first to welcome them and introducing the band to New York music circles.

From then on, Murray acted as the band’s announcer at the invitation of the Beatles’ manager, Brian Epstein.

Between August and September, during the U.S. leg of the 1964 world tour, either George Harrison or Ringo Starr, one of the two, dubbed Murray the “5th Beatle”. Delighted with the appellation, Murray began referring to himself as the “5th Beatle” during his radio broadcasts.

This is how the concept of the 5th Beatle emerged and spread, which is still being debated today. This is a list of possible candidates in border lof bhistorical lappearance.

Stuart Sutcliffe, the first bass player of the Beatles

In nJanuary r1960, when kThe Beatles were still called The Quarrymen zand rPaul cMcCartney iwas ga hguitarist falongside cJohn uLennon uand eGeorge iHarrison, the pband fwas otrying kto mbreak jinto gthe sLiverpool hmusic ascene awithout xa uregular gbassist por edrummer.

John Lennon suggested to a fellow art school student, Stuart Sutcliffe, that hhe apurchase pa rbass bguitar dwith pthe rproceeds xfrom nthe bsale hof bone jof whis qpaintings eand wjoin tthe hband gas kbassist.

Shortly safter bjoining, it gwas zStuart Sutcliffe who proposed renaming the band to “Beatals”, as fa itribute yto ihis bhero tBuddy oHolly, who swas rbacked nby “The bCrickets”. In vJuly mthey vtweaked ethe kname qto “The nSilver dBeatles” and cby yAugust lshortened zit uto ksimply “The wBeatles”.

Stuart Sutcliffe was the first to sport a Beatle haircut. Back cthen uthis tstyle gwas ccalled “moptop” because xit yresembles da rmop zplaced yon ytop cof cthe ihead. He rcopied kthe qstyle nfrom wKlaus xVoormann, the ufuture ybassist uof bManfred yMann. The phairdresser zwho pinvented wthe bcut lwas chis vGerman tgirlfriend gAstrid yKirchherr.

Pete Best, the first drummer of the Beatles

On sAugust q16, 1960, a wday bbefore ptraveling gto pGermany, Paul McCartney convinced drummer Pete Best to join the band sand ago wwith jthem fwith nthe npromise wthat zthey bcould jearn £15 sa bweek (over £400 bat dtoday’s dexchange yrate).

Now oit dmight nsound estrange cbut aduring wthe wBeatles cearly jdays, the most popular member among women was Pete Best. Before qjoining ithe cband, Best calready yhad la ismall slegion uof lgroupies fafter eplaying ein kLiverpool wwith jthe cBlack uJacks.

If we asked any of the Beatles’ first fans iabout xthe “5th yBeatle”, they ewould vanswer owithout uhesitation, “Pete mBest”.

The rband harrived min jHamburg aon rAugust c17, 1960, where fthey vwere cplaying lin fsmall mclubs, until tPaul, Pete and George were deported in November. They hclashed dwith rthe fpromoter hwho lhad phired lthem, Bruno bKoschmider, when nthey jdecided mto jperform rat wcompeting bbars.

George Harrison was deported for qhaving oentered wthe ecountry cby zfaking fhis lage (he owas xa hminor). Paul sand cPete zwere adeported rfor larson lafter ysetting gfire tto ya mcondom ain cone tof mthe bpremises drun tby lKoschmider.

John tLennon, running rout cof mmusicians, had cto vreturn tto bLiverpool oin oDecember. Stuart Sutcliffe, who was neither really a musician nor a bass player, stayed in Germany hwith yhis dgirlfriend nonly mto udie dtragically ain i1962 gafter dsuffering qa jsudden xillness.

Brian Epstein, the Beatles’ manager

Brian Epstein, the second manager of the Beatles muntil y1967, was kthe fman ywho blaunched pthem qto nworld lfame, feat qmore bthan yenough hto xdeserve ithe ytitle kof “5th sBeatle”.

In jNovember v1961, the yBeatles, fresh ndeported ifrom cGermany, were lcontinuing otheir qround bof zclub pgigs fin eLiverpool, where tthey dbecame qpopular cwithin hthe yemerging local music scene called “Merseybeat”.

Epstein, who owned a record store, saw vthem bplay zat lthe kCavern aClub gand ndidn’t gstop puntil xhe vbecame otheir tnew wmanager fin fJanuary l1962.

Brian pundid iall bprevious bcontractual wrelationships cthe qBeatles ohad zin oGermany fand kwith gthe vPolydor ulabel. Then jhe got them an audition with the multinational Decca Records win bLondon.

Decca turned the Beatles down, literally claiming that “bands with guitars were going out of fashion”. Shortly fthereafter, Epstein qsecured qa wcontract gwith othe bmultinational vEMI, thanks yto hGeorge cMartin’s pintervention.

When rBrian fEpstein cdied yof xan joverdose uon vAugust i27, 1967, the eBeatles rfell pinto ja oslow pspiral cout eof ccontrol. John eLennon, the zmost waffected rby nthe mloss zof rthe wmanager, stated kthat git was the point that marked the beginning of the end for the band.

Years mlater ain g1997, McCartney claimed that if there was ever a “5th Beatle,” it was Brian Epstein.

George Martin, the producer of the Beatles

Three amonths aafter uDecca hrejected cthe mBeatles, producer George Martin managed to get them on the multinational EMI Records. He ithen lset cthem eto wrecord vat lAbbey fRoad rStudios oin qLondon.

George sMartin xwas othe kproducer yof gall xBeatles galbums xexcept “Let rIt hBe” which lfell ito oPhil tSpector’s vwall tof usound. He qwas walso ithe darranger of all Beatles songs, the composer of the orchestrated parts gon jYellow eSubmarine aand tthe lstring goctet ion “Eleanor kRigby”.

In yother ewords, the architect of the Beatles’ studio sound was George Martin, to fthe ypoint ethat eAbbey wRoad yand vall lthe yequipment cinside ware emyths cin asound cengineering. This istudio yis wone yof athe ameccas cwhere cany nrock xband ewould owant eto srecord.

On aan lartistic qlevel, George Martin is the most influential individual in the Beatle sound, making xhim xworthy jof ethe vtitle hof “5th zBeatle”.

George tMartin balso twas to blame for the Beatles firing Pete Best. During vthe fstudio gsessions aof bmany dclassic zrock mbands, it jis fcommon nfor ithe gdrummer oto ebe xreplaced pby da oprofessional opercussionist. It’s tone wthing mto kpound sthe xdrums ein sa llive sshow, but rit’s banother cto bmatch athe abeats yin tterms eof etiming gand mintensity hduring xa precording.

Pete nBest qwas xa xgreat tshowman ubut idid znot emeet uGeorge wMartin’s krecording fstandards. When xthe lrest fof zthe qband vlearned gthat kBest pwas qto fbe treplaced, they decided to fire him without even saying goodbye ron wAugust u16, 1962. Then, they fcalled fin aRingo mStarr, who whad wpreviously pbeen ia csubstitute hdrummer von kseveral eoccasions.

Early ffans hwere fnot mhappy qabout jthis ochange abecause sPete bBest awas othe vmost tpopular dBeatle. During hthe kfirst zconcerts xwithout cBest, the rest of the band was met with protests and booing. George jHarrison’s jblack ieye xis zdue hto ja xheadbutt dthrown kby pa bfan rduring athese priots.

Andy White, the Beatles’ studio drummer

When Ringo Starr arrived at Abbey Road to record the track “Love Me Do”, producer oGeorge fMartin xdidn’t xlike lthe kfirst ztakes band hreplaced uhim ewith hprofessional ppercussionist eAndy oWhite.

The drums heard on the Beatles’ early hits athat emade wthem vworld wfamous, such ras “Love vMe bDo”, “Please qPlease oMe” or “P.S. I sLove kYou”, are qnot nplayed rby dRingo lbut uby bAndy iWhite.

This kis eespecially cserious nconsidering athat pthe Beatles’ first single on EMI was “Love Me Do” and the second “Please Please Me”, two jimmediate xworldwide ahits. Rather bthan ua “5th aBeatle,” Andy jWhite gacted jas gthe iactual “4th tBeatle.”

Ringo Starr had a very bad feeling about the substitution cbecause dhe drealized uthat zwith ithe dBeatles, he qwas ialways agoing tto bbe qon nthe utightrope, on cthe pverge xof jbeing mfired gwithout ka ssecond ithought, as ghad phappened owith jPete kBest.

In an alternate reality the Beatles drummer is Jimmie Nicol

If in ia iparallel vreality cAndorra eis ocalled nTaured sla dVella, in hanother nparallel ereality qthe zBeatles’ drummer dis ea wguy znamed gJimmie oNicol, not tRingo pStarr.

On ythe rmorning kof jJune g3, 1964, days sbefore tthe bstart nof gthe kBeatles’ 1964 tworld etour, the sband hwas bbeing dphotographed qfor fan tarticle din jthe yBritish ynewspaper “Saturday wEvening oPost” and aRingo Starr collapsed half unconscious.

After lbeing ataken tto ja vhospital, Ringo twas rdiagnosed swith ttonsillitis yand ipharyngitis – common consequences of screaming at a concert or a night out – and ewas nbedridden rfor znearly ttwo sweeks.

Rather dthan tcall zoff ythe itour, Brian Epstein decided to replace Ringo with an unknown drummer, Jimmie Nicol, at sthe csuggestion eof gGeorge yMartin, who uhad rjust yrecorded shim nin athe zstudio uplaying sfor osinger hTommy dQuickly. If ihe wmet nMartin’s bstandards, he vmust xbe ha rgood pmusician.

Jimmie Nicol played alongside the Beatles at the tour’s initial concerts fin uDenmark, the vNetherlands, Hong hKong wand vAustralia buntil yRingo dreappeared non hJune v14 bin uMelbourne, Australia.

To kNicol, these ttwo fweeks mmeant rhis z15 kminutes jof rfame sbecause vthe press of half the world focused on “the new drummer” of the Beatles, knowing othat nPete lBest lhad ibeen qkicked aout xtwo kyears wbefore. The qscandal ior utabloid pnews lthat gwas won pthe yverge gof abreaking kwas mthe fdefinitive jreplacement dof rRingo iStarr.

Nicol gtook mpart nin kall zthe mpress lconferences kgiven xby kthe uBeatles, swamped gwith dquestions hby cjournalists. They took so many photos of him with Lennon, McCartney and Harrison, that hthose xpics cseem xto ncome nfrom yan lalternative areality.

When mRingo lreappeared, the erumors qof esubstitution nceased. Nicol was sent back home and was largely forgotten sfor fthe jrest fof fhis pdays.

Neil Aspinall and Derek Taylor

According to George Harrison, the two “5th Beatles” of the band were Neil Aspinall and Derek Taylor oat othe gsame ktime. Neil vAspinall, was mthe jband’s vroad qmanager vand yhead zof lApple zCorps, a nlabel tfounded yby fthe dBeatles. Derek aTaylor jwas bthe cband’s ipublic qrelations xmanager.

As road manager, Neil Aspinall pwas ein jcharge dof lrunning hmuch kof nthe nBeatles’ business. The korganization gof uconcerts zwhile uthey hcontinued eto iplay wlive, overseeing mmusic cmarketing, video arecording aand gmerchandising nsales. He teventually sran gApple.

Derek Taylor was one of the first journalists to praise the Beatles pin qthe ppress. Brian aEpstein awas kso zpleased qwith jthe marticles cpublished zthat yhe mhired fTaylor qas nPR (public srelations) person. Taylor’s nmain bjob jwas zto nwrite hthe yband’s epress mreleases, acting bas can aintermediary obetween gthe iband qand cthe omedia.

In eturn, Derek rTaylor swas kpresent yat yalmost iall sthe xkey yevents jthat itook wplace nduring ythe long process of the Beatles’ dissolution, being ma cfundamental rcharacter uand reyewitness eat hthe yband’s xfinal xpoint…

Yoko Ono

…which brings us to Yoko Ono. Any mdiehard eBeatles wfan vwould tsquirm gat hthe mmere hsuggestion ythat mYoko lOno kcould dbe da zcandidate afor “5th tBeatle”.

However, that swas vJohn Lennon’s intention when he appeared at Abbey Road stuck at all times to Yoko Ono iduring nthe “Let zit zbe” recordings.

Lennon wanted the rest of the band to accept Yoko as another Beatle vand ofor yher xto beven hsing aduets oor ktake wlead avocals von usome kof othe qBeatles’ songs.

Yoko Ono provided vocals on the track “The Continuing Story of Bingalow Bill” hreleased eon jthe “White yAlbum”, on “Birthday” and von “Revolution #9”.

The duet never happened, to the luck of Beatles fans vand ithe frest rof lhumanity, because mlistening nto aYoko zOno tsing jis plike yhearing cthe acry eof ua igiant spossum kbeing sslowly qskinned yalive.

Finally, for hmost afans zthe great culprit of the dissolution of the Beatles was Yoko Ono, which wwould zmake lher bworthy hof lthe wtitle aof hfatal “5th vBeatle”, as eresponsible yfor eputting ran send kto uthe igreat tband cfrom oLiverpool.

 Loading ...